Spank Or Don't Spank

Tools

Spank Or Don't Spank

By Caitlin Haedicke

Knowing how to discipline a child is tough and different for every family. There's timeouts, taking away toys, and sending them to their room. Spanking is another highly debated option. In fact, 19 countries have actually banned the action.

It's legal in all 50 states for a parent to spank their child. But that doesn't mean all parents or experts agree on the action.

Every parent has had to deal with it: a child screaming, throwing a fit, and not listening. This type of behavior usually comes with a consequence.

"If they misbehave, they lose their movie time and they really get upset when they lose their movie time," said Wendy Miller, a mom of two.  

Kjerstin Smith, a mother of two, said, "Somebody gave me the advice that if they're out of control, the best thing you can do is shrink down their environment."

"We've done time outs a lot and spanking for things like hitting and we'll do that because we need to stop those actions that are dangerous to other children," stated Jennifer Noble, a mother of three.

Spanking has long been debated as a form of punishment and the reasons for it and against it vary. For Wendy Miller, it's about the way her parents punished.  She wasn't spanked and doesn't want her children to be either stating, "Through the way I was raised, I just don't feel it's the right thing, the right way, to do it. There's other ways of punishing them and letting them know it was wrong."

Kjerstin Smith found when it comes to her boys, a spanking stops the action, but doesn't keep it from happening again. She said, "I have resorted to it once or twice to get attention, especially in a dangerous situation, but I've also found the lasting effects aren't there in terms of changing the behavior long term."

And with her three kids, Jennifer Noble says spanking helps teach them right from wrong stating, "They have that happen a couple times and they think 'OK, I don't want to do that.  I add one plus one equals two and no! I want to stop because I don't want that consequence.'"

But who's reasoning is right? Deb Aden Ripperda, Assistant Director of Social Work at the University of Sioux Falls, says the debate continues, stating, "Should we or shouldn't we? I mean, what kind of discipline is in the best interest of the child?"

While it may be hard, Deb says parents need to step back from the situation before any action is taken. There can be a fine line between spanking and abuse.

"Never discipline out of anger. You as a parent need to stop, look, and listen, or stop think and listen, and just take some deep breaths," said Aden Ripperda.

Aden says many parents punish their children the same way they were punished. After all, we learn what we live. But she says parenting classes are never a bad idea. Aden Ripperda stated, "Would you go to a doctor that hasn't done their research or kept up on the times in 20 years? So if you're raising your child the way you were raised twenty years ago, you haven't upgraded your parenting skills whatsoever."

We tried to reach quite a few experts on the subject and many didn't want to comment. For those who did, and according to many parenting books, spanking isn't seen an effective form of punishment.

"The research that I've studied shows that it does diminish the child's self esteem. That it does show aggression in a child," said Aden Ripperda.  

Each parent must use their own judgment and use what works for them.

"Much of the time, parenting is hit or miss and sometimes you make mistakes, but you do the best you can and you let your kids know that you love them," said Smith.

Deb Aden Ripperda suggests keeping the action you use consistent so your child can recognize when they're doing something wrong. For tips on how to make discipline stick, tune in Wednesday for KSFY Live In The Morning.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of KSFY.com. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Sunday, Sep 7 at 10:49 PM mays5 wrote ...

Although I'm not anti-spanking, I do believe other forms of discipline are more effective in general. As a mom to 3, we use timeouts, redirection, removal of privileges/toys to curb poor behavior. There's a really good debate about whether to spank or not at www.opposingviews.com/questions/is-spanking-an-acceptable-form-of-discipline. Experts from both sides weigh in and make some thought-provoking points on the topic.

Thursday, May 1 at 12:04 PM get a grip wrote ...

As parents it is up to us to use judgement to discipline our children. If spanking is what is needed then spank them, if it can be handled verbally then do so. Spanking a child is no worse than verbally abusing children. Again, we as parents need to make a judgement call and do what we feel is best for our children within the confines of the law. No child deserves to be physically or verbally abused.

Thursday, May 1 at 11:59 AM old school wrote ...

a good part of the problems that our country has with teens today is a direct result of no disicpline from our newage parents. Spank away, but do not abuse & while yor at teach some respect.

Thursday, May 1 at 7:27 AM Jay wrote ...

I find the title of this story interesting.

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 11:49 PM wow wrote ...

Theres no more troubled kids today then there were 15 to 20 years ago. You so called " mothers " dont know what your talking about.

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 6:08 PM Anonymous wrote ...

My parents did spank my siblings and I - but it was only when we really misbehaved; said spanking was usually delivered while being led to our room for a time-out. It is not the act of spanking that we need to be careful of, it is WHEN and HOW OFTEN. Too many parents are too scared to discipline their kids anymore; it is why we have so manny teenage / twenty-something troublemakers out there today!

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 1:29 PM Seen it before! wrote ...

Spare the rod and spoil the child. If you don't plan on parenting, don't pretend to be a responsible Mom or Dad. The majority of social ills are directly traced to "parents" who don't say no to their children and probably didn't want the child in the first place. Violence, abuse, drugs, lack of integrity, can all be linked to the parents and the lack of values that were taught to the offspring. Don't wait until the Courts sentence your little darling to a "time out." Teach "right from wrong."

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 12:30 PM Anonymous wrote ...

"mom, must be one of those parents that talks like a baby to her kids and says things like honey sweetie pie, you should not throw knives at your baby brother..it could hurt him. LOL Sometimes spanking is justified. Abuse is not. Pretty soon time-out will be considered child abuse.

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 9:00 AM Megan wrote ...

I am a mother of 4 and use spanking when its needed. But what some parents forget is that there is a huge diffrence between spanking to discipline and spanking to abuse the child. Society today is so worried about what everyone else thinks and maybe thats why we have so many troubled kids now days. Dicipline still needs to happen use common sense!

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 8:10 AM Viewer in SF wrote ...

My parents spanked me and my siblings were growing up, but only if we had done something really wrong. We knew that when we were spanked we had really done something wrong and deserved the punishment we were getting. I see way too many parents who just yell or holler at their kids to try to correct misbehavior and the kids just become immune to it and just tune out the parent(s). I am definitely in favor of spanking to discipline (not beating).

Wednesday, Apr 30 at 6:01 AM A mom wrote ...

Spanking is just another word for hitting. Teaching a child that spanking/hitting them is good for them. That type of so called discipline should never be used!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

KSFY.com and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

Stock Quotes

Flash Poll

Do you agree with the new recommendation that women should wait until they are 21 to get their first pap smear test?

  • Yes
  • No

AP Video