States Consider Fake Gun Ban

Tools

States Consider Fake Gun Ban

By Caitlin Haedicke

Lawmakers from 15 states are setting their sights on toy guns. They have all proposed bills seeking some sort of punishment for the use or display of a toy gun in places like vehicles or stores.  One of the major issues with toy guns is their similarity to real guns. Any kids could pull off this orange cap and a police officer wouldn't be able to tell the difference. And that can end in a very tragic situation.

David Woldt keeps guns, fake or real, out of his house and away from his children. He knows the affects guns can have and how real a toy gun can look.

"I don't really care much for them because just the fact that someone could be a little ways away and it could be a real gun. Doesn't matter what color it is," said David Woldt, a Sioux Falls father of two.

That likeness is the reason lawmakers are searching for a change. They're worried plastic guns are confusing police. Even Sioux Falls Police admit it's hard to tell them apart.

"No you can't. Even when toy guns have been painting a different color," stated Sgt. David McIntire with the Sioux Falls Police Department.  

Federal law requires toy guns or imitations to be orange-tipped. But for some lawmakers, that doesn't go far enough since it's easy to paint over the orange. And it's just as easy to make a real gun look fake.

"For a long time, criminals have been painting their guns different colors just to get police to hesitate," said Sgt. McIntire. 

That confusion forces police to take every situation seriously and take the appropriate action.

McIntire stated, "Every situations different, but like I said before, if it looks like a gun, it's considered a gun until we figure out otherwise."

Sergeant McIntire isn't sure if banning toy guns is the right move.

"I don't know that that's necessarily the answer. Toy guns themselves are not the problem.  It's people's behavior," said Sgt. McIntire. 

But David would like to see them gone.

"I don't want guns around. Like the little play guns and stuff. Even in the stores, " said Woldt.  

The National Rifle Association has responded by saying such legislation is "silly" because it doesn't deal with the issues of crime.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of KSFY.com. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Wednesday, May 7 at 1:53 PM Michael wrote ...

You can't get much more absurd than this, but I know you slobbering feel-gooders will try. Check out the video games your kids are playing, then try to figure out where their violent attitudes are coming from. Guns, knives, baseball bats and Barbie dolls aren't the problem. Lack of solid parental guidance and discipline, based on a scriptural moral foundation, coupled with too much governmental interferance in the family, is the problem.

Tuesday, May 6 at 8:14 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Give me a break, what's next, let's ban hair dryers because they could look like a gun too. Same old sad story with this country, let's punish the good folks because we aren't bright enough to punish those who really deserve it. Pretty soon we won't be able to do anything. Ideas like this are what is ruining our great country

Tuesday, May 6 at 3:22 PM BESTSHOT wrote ...

ALL THE KIDS I GREW UP WITH TURNED OUT FINE AND WE ALL HAD PLAY GUNS! THEY ARE SOLDIERS STATESMEN AND LEADERS OF OUR SOCIETY!!! THERE WERE NOT MANY MISLED UNEDUCATED PEOPLE AROUND THAT WERE ALLOWED TO TRAMPLE ON OTHER PEOPLES RIGHTS BACK THEN!!! WOULD YOU RATHER YOUR KIDS THROW ROCKS AT EACH OTHER OR PLAY WITH TOY GUNS? WE PLAYED COPS AND ROBBERS AND SUCH AND IT HELPED US TO SEE RIGHT AND WRONG WITHOUT DANGER!!! PLEASE LET PARENTS MONITOR THIER OWN CHILDREN !!! YOU HAVE NO RIGHT!!!

Tuesday, May 6 at 12:43 PM James H. Black wrote ...

This is some of the dumbest legislation I have seen in quite a while. People who are afraid of guns are using a fantasy as justification for banning toy guns. No where in the story does it mention any officially documented instances where a child with an orage-tipped toy gun was shot by police, or where a criminal altered the appearance of a real gun to fool the police. This is a poorly researched story that is merely anti-gun propoganda.

Tuesday, May 6 at 8:38 AM Pete wrote ...

Careful, kids. A cop might shoot you.

Monday, May 5 at 8:06 AM jzumrick wrote ...

The title is 15 states consider fake gun ban. So who are those 15 states? Without this information how can the reader be sure this piece was carefully researched.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

KSFY.com and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

Stock Quotes

Flash Poll

Have you received a seasonal flu shot yet?

  • Yes
  • No
  • I have not, but members of my family have.

AP Video