Battle Over Exceptions

Tools

Battle Over Exceptions

KSFY file image.

By Kent Erdahl

Tuesday, South Dakotans will once again go to the polls to vote on a proposed abortion ban. In 2006, a ban on nearly all abortions was voted down by 12 percentage points. This year the vote is expected to be much closer. That's because Initiated Measure 11 includes exceptions for rape, incest and if the mother's health is at a substantial and irreversible risk.

That health exception has been at the center of debate throughout the past few weeks and it could ultimately decide the vote. Two women with personal stakes in the debate explain why they've taken sides on Measure 11.

Many volunteers have made their voices heard on both sides of the abortion debate, but for Rachel Rieman and Tiffany Campbell, their passion for and against Measure 11 goes much deeper than signs on street corners.

Shortly after Rachel Rieman got pregnant at the age of 19, doctors could see her daughter was missing the top part of her brain. It's one of many cases referred to as a Fatal Fetal Anomaly.

Rachel Rieman says, "They told me her condition was incompatible with life and that I should terminate the pregnancy."

Instead, Rachel decided to go through with her pregnancy and, despite her doctors predictions, her daughter lived outside the womb for 32 days.

Under Measure 11, women facing similar situations would be required to go through with their pregnancy. Rachel says she's proof that is a good thing.

Rachel Rieman says, "That child may die either way, but you never know if you end it in termination, what's really going to happen. what you missed out on."

Tiffany Campbell has been the face of a television campaign against Measure 11 saying the ban would have prevented her from making a difficult choice.

Tiffany Campbell says, "We had 24 hours to decide if we'd end one boy's life to save the other."

Tiffany's case, which involves Twin to Twin Transfusion Syndrome, has been scrutinized by doctors supporting Measure 11, who say she had other options. Tiffany says she only had one choice to ensure either son survived.

Tiffany Campbell says, "I know I played a role in my son's death. I live with that every single day. But then I also look at Brady and I see why I had to do it."

Even on the side streets across the state it's easy to see how heated this debate is, even between neighbors, but both women say that won't stop them from campaigning until election day, even when their passions intersect at the same street corner.

Rachel Rieman says, "We just want people to know that we're here to help save babies and protect women from abortion."

Tiffany Campbell says, "My child would not be here if Measure 11 was in place two years ago."

Recent voter polls indicate an even split between those for and against Measure 11.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of KSFY.com. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Sunday, Nov 2 at 10:39 PM rogers2000 wrote ...

There was another option to save these twin boys (both) http://wcco.com/health/ttts.surgery.twins.2.848426.html

Monday, Nov 3 at 1:28 AM Rural SD wrote ...

Sounds like this issue is focusing on a few unfortunate cases, not the whole picture. What percent of abortions are done in South Dakota for cases like these?

Monday, Nov 3 at 5:47 AM Anonymous wrote ...

i am sure all of the "rv" voters from out of state plan to vote for this measure...its sad when the true sd residents arent allowed to deciede on thier own.

Monday, Nov 3 at 12:38 PM Anon wrote ...

Abortion is not the problem. Abortion is the current (albeit negative)solution to the problem. The problem is a lack of sexual education and promiscuity amongst our younger SD residents. Banning abortions won't get rid of the problem. Do you think people will stop getting pregnant just because abortion is no longer an option? No. This ban will hurt women and take away the current option they have. Until they PROBLEM is solved, we can't take away the SOLUTION.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

KSFY.com and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

Stock Quotes

Flash Poll

Do you agree with the new recommendation that women should wait until they are 21 to get their first pap smear test?

  • Yes
  • No

AP Video