Avera Medical Minute: Importance of Vaccinations

Tools

By Nancy Naeve Brown

Most of us probably don't remember it, but the first 5 years of our lives were filled with regularly scheduled trips to the doctor's office.   Childhood immunizations were done without question in "our day" but today is much different. A lot of parents are questioning whether those vaccines could actually hurt the children they are intended to protect.  We talk to a Sioux Falls Pediatrician who says if you don't trust the government who insists it's far riskier to skip the shots... trust your doctor.

You can't open a magazine these days without reading something about the controversial debate over vaccinations and autism. actress Jenny McCarthy is leading the charge encouraging all of you not to immunize your child because it causes autism. Main McGreevy Clinic Avera Pediatrician Dr. Kara Bruning says that's very dangerous advice. Advice, she says, you shouldn't take from people in Hollywood.

Dr. Bruning says, "Even just to Google vaccine you see a lot of bad info on them. Talk to your doctor find the good websites, the good information rather than listen to people who don't have any medical background."

One of the ingredients in question is thimerosal. A preservative with trace amounts of mercury that was used to prevent bacteria and fungus from growing in those vaccines before they're used.

Dr. Bruning says, "Even though it was proven that thimerasol didn't cause autism, they took it out of all vaccines anyway because of concerns. It's only still present in the influenza vaccine and that's only given to adults not to babies."

But what about the connection between vaccines and the growing rate of autism in this country? Now 1 in 150 children are affected by it.

Dr. Bruning says, "The problem is a report that came out in 1986 that looked at 12 children who got autism because of thimerasol. If you go back and look 10 of the 12 authors recanted. It was a bad study. They didn't get enough information. And yet that misinformation is still out there."

And information, the RIGHT information, is what Dr. Kara Bruning wants you to be armed with.. when it's time for your kids to bare their arms.

She says, "Measles, still out there. Rubella is still out there.  Mumps is still out there. If you watch the news you see in the last few years people are coming down with these diseases. Chicken pox is still a disease that can kill you. And all those are vaccine preventable illnesses. There are risks associated with vaccines but there are risks associated with getting into the car. There's risks associated with everything, but it's far riskier if you don't vaccinate your child."

South Dakota Department of Health
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

 

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of KSFY.com. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Tuesday, Aug 19 at 1:22 AM Chicago Pediatrician wrote ...

Part of the probles as I see it has always been confounding of fact by anti-vax groups. They put out incongrous math miscalculating numbers to confuse the public. The joke is that the authority is being taken out of the hands of the experts, the physicians. In that case, good luck calculating how much antibiotics to give and which type for your child's next ear infection; good luck reading x-rays to diagnose pneumonias; good luck replacing your grandpa's worn-out knees. Let experts be experts

Friday, Aug 8 at 3:35 PM Great website wrote ...

www.vaccinateyourbaby.org

Thursday, Aug 7 at 10:39 PM Epi Wonk wrote ...

A good website of the sort that Dr. Bruning mentions is the National Network for Immunization Information, www.immunizationinfo.org.

Thursday, Aug 7 at 10:05 AM Dave wrote ...

Please read http://recoveringnicholas.com/2008/08/06/must-read-cornelia-reads-a-shot-in-the-dark/

Thursday, Aug 7 at 8:53 AM Smarter Vaccinations wrote ...

http://www.bismarcktribune.com/articles/2008/03/24/news/opinion/letters/151637.txt Interesting point of view at link above. Having been born in 1970, I remember going to get about 10 vaccines before 5 not 36 before 3. There has never been good science on protocol comparisons. The CDC's protocol is not even the most efficacious because of immuno-interference from maternal antibodies still in infant circulation while the bulk of the vaccine schedule is being given.

Thursday, Aug 7 at 7:18 AM Autism News Beat wrote ...

Gary, a tuna fish sandwich has 20 mics of Hg. Thimerosal is ethyl Hg, which clears the body faster than methyl. The petri dish example you give is irrelevant to the discussion. Autism is distinct from mercury poisoning. If the two were related, the effects would have been detected in at least one of the 20 or so epi studies that have looked at the matter.

Thursday, Aug 7 at 7:00 AM Joe wrote ...

Is this article a joke? I've never seen so many inaccurate statements in my life. BTW, thimerosal is 50% mercury.

Thursday, Aug 7 at 1:25 AM Gary S. Goldman, Ph.D. wrote ...

Vaccines with “trace” amounts of Thimerosal, by definition, “contain less than 1 microgram of mercury (Hg) per dose.” For example, consider that the reduced-Thimerosal flu vaccine with 0.0002% mercury is equivalent to 1 microgram [µg] of Hg per 0.5 mL, or 2 µg of Hg per mL, which is the same as 2000 parts per billion [ppb]. 0.5 ppb mercury has been shown to kill human neuroblastoma cells; 200 ppb is the level in liquid that the EPA classifies as hazardous waste.

Wednesday, Aug 6 at 11:58 PM Autism News Beat wrote ...

"The problem is a report that came out in 1986 that looked at 12 children who got autism because of thimerasol. If you go back and look 10 of the 12 authors recanted." Dr. Bruning is talking about Wakefield's 1998 MMR study. There's never been thimerosal in MMR. I think the reporter misquoted her. Thanks for speaking out, Dr. Bruning.

Wednesday, Aug 6 at 9:25 PM Sarah wrote ...

As a mother of a 6 month old, I am disappointed when I hear people who choose not to vaccinate because of a supposed link to autism. They are putting their babies at risk and are relying on other babies' vaccinations to protect their own children. Research has shown that babies and toddlers diagnosed with autism were predisposed to autism; the vaccinations were a coincidence.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

Comments are moderated and will not appear on this story until after they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

KSFY.com and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

Action News Weather


Icon
Sioux Falls 14 °F
Overcast
Wind : From the West at 7 MPH
Humidity : 71 %
Pressure : 30.49" (1035.4 mb)
Aberdeen 13 °F
Pierre 17 °F
More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

AP Video