WARNING: Some may consider the content of this story graphic.
A fourth person has come forward to say she was raped by Werner Fajardo, 35, at the El Cuervo Bar in Huron.
The girl was 18 at the time of the alleged crime. She testified that Fajardo forced her to have sex with him sometime in early September 2011. The girl said she and a friend were in the bar after hours when the supposed incident happened.
For what seems to be the first time, a jury heard what could be Fajardo's side to the story. During Detective Gene Miller's testimony, he said Fajardo read the warrant for his arrest and recognized one of the victim's names. Detective Miller said during an interview Fajardo claimed he was being set up.
Earlier Thursday, the three younger victims provided graphic accounts of the October 30 night at the El Cuervo Bar.
As the prosecution called each victim it was revealed that a text message could have started the alleged incident. The girls left one of the homes after babysitting that night and allegedly texted Fajardo for a ride. However, investigators' testified they were unable to recover any such text messages. They claimed the data was lost and unobtainable because the investigation started weeks after the incident.
One of the victims told the jury Fajardo picked them up and took them to El Cuervo Bar, but they had to wait outside before they could enter. The victim said Fajardo let them in through the backdoor.
During the investigation, Fajardo confirmed to police the girls were at the bar October 30. He said he did not take them home because they were already intoxicated and he didn't want to drive with them in his car.
The victims said they sat down, hung out and drank vodka mixed with Monster energy drink, beer and shots—all allegedly served by Fajardo. One victim said they were also listening to music and dancing on the stage in the bar.
According to the 12-year-old victim's testimony, one of the girls passed out in a booth while the other passed out in the bathroom. The 12-year-old was still up with Fajardo who said he was going to drive to Wal Mart and buy an air mattress. The victim said before Fajardo left he tried kissing her stomach, but she pushed him away and called him a pervert.
Investigators found Fajardo did actually go to Wal Mart and purchased an air mattress and comforter at 5:04 a.m.
Meanwhile, the 12-year-old victim tried leaving through the front door, but she couldn't get out. She said she did not think to try the backdoor. After that attempt she said she tried waking up her friends but she couldn't. The victim said she gave up, drank a beer and went to sleep because she was tired.
The victim said later that night she woke up to find Fajardo at her knees having sex with her. She said she tried to break free but couldn't.
"I couldn't move. I tried kicking my legs, but I couldn't move. I was frozen," the girl said.
She said she passed out and woke up two more times and each time she woke up Fajardo was either raping or licking her.
The victim said when she woke up the next morning, both her friends had left and it was only her and Fajardo in the El Cuervo Bar. She said she started yelling at Fajardo and asked for her phone and shoes.
The victim said eventually Fajardo gave her a ride home. She said it was awkward and claimed before Fajardo dropped her off he touched her leg and said, "You weren't like that last night."
The other girls' testimonies claimed the same graphic recollections. They claimed to wake up to Fajardo pulling their pants down and licking their private areas.
The defense spent most of its cross examinations trying to tear open potential holes in the victim testimonies and their statements to police. The defense had the girls re-read their police statements to connect the testimonies they provided. The girls had difficulty remembering the amount of drinks they had. The defense also tried clarifying whether Fajardo actually licked one of the girls or just touched one.
The defense spent part of the afternoon trying to poke holes in the investigation as well. The asked who was interviewed and what processes were used to gather evidence. One piece of evidence was a condom wrapper found on the floor under a booth in the bar. The defense made a point of noting it was found 20 days after the alleged incident.
Testimonies will continue in the trial Friday morning. Lawyers expect to have the case to the jury by Friday afternoon.
Wednesday, April 16 2014 5:09 PM EDT2014-04-16 21:09:39 GMT
"What kind of person would come in and steal puppies?" Ed Anderson, owner of Ed's Pet World in Mitchell, is trying to find out. He came to work yesterday morning to find his cash register destroyed, merchandiseMore >>
"What kind of person would come in and steal puppies?" Ed Anderson, owner of Ed's Pet World in Mitchell, is trying to find out.More >>
Wednesday, April 16 2014 3:50 PM EDT2014-04-16 19:50:24 GMT
South Dakota U.S. Senate candidates talking about the idled Northern Beef Packers have been tossing out figures of taxpayer losses ranging from zero dollars to $80 million. A breakdown from state agenciesMore >>
South Dakota U.S. Senate candidates talking about the idled Northern Beef Packers have been tossing out figures of taxpayer losses ranging from zero dollars to $80 million.More >>
Wednesday, April 16 2014 3:34 PM EDT2014-04-16 19:34:01 GMT
The mother of the 3-year-old Nebraska boy who was reported missing before being found safe inside a claw machine at a nearby bowling alley will not face charges. The mother, who was not identified, calledMore >>
The mother of the 3-year-old Nebraska boy who was reported missing before being found safe inside a claw machine at a nearby bowling alley will not face charges.More >>
Wednesday, April 16 2014 2:34 PM EDT2014-04-16 18:34:54 GMT
(CNN) -- Military dive teams and other rescuers worked the dark, cold waters of the Yellow Sea early Thursday in a desperate effort to find nearly 300 people who remained missing after the ferry theyMore >>
Military dive teams and other rescuers worked the dark, cold waters of the Yellow Sea early Thursday in a desperate effort to find nearly 300 people who remained missing after the ferry they were taking to a South Korean island resort sank with breathtaking speed.More >>
Wednesday, April 16 2014 2:30 PM EDT2014-04-16 18:30:52 GMT
STURGIS -- The company Indian Motorcycles plans to open a permanent dealership in Sturgis. The Rapid City Journal reports the company's push to re-establish as a major player in cycle city will challengeMore >>
The company Indian Motorcycles plans to open a permanent dealership in Sturgis.More >>
Wednesday, April 16 2014 2:25 PM EDT2014-04-16 18:25:43 GMT
The man arrested near the Boston Marathon finish line carrying a backpack containing a rice cooker on the anniversary of the bombings was sent to a state psychiatric facility for an evaluation WednesdayMore >>
The man arrested near the Boston Marathon finish line carrying a backpack containing a rice cooker on the anniversary of the bombings was sent to a state psychiatric facility for an evaluation Wednesday following his initial court appearance.More >>
Wednesday, April 16 2014 2:14 PM EDT2014-04-16 18:14:06 GMT
Dr. Jeff Krall kept hearing about the same eye-related symptoms, resulting in another headache for his patients. After ten years of research, the Mitchell optometrist came to a conclusion. "We have foundMore >>
The symptoms are quite common - you get sleepy while reading a book or your eyes feel gritty and burn. Suddenly, you've got a headache, which a local optometrist specifically calls an eyeGraine.
Wednesday, April 16 2014 1:53 PM EDT2014-04-16 17:53:30 GMT
Investigators are reconstructing a mysterious decade from Megan Huntsman's life as they try to figure out how she concealed seven pregnancies before allegedly strangling or suffocating her newborns. UtahMore >>
Investigators are reconstructing a mysterious decade from Megan Huntsman's life as they try to figure out how she concealed seven pregnancies before allegedly strangling or suffocating her newborns.More >>