South Dakota's highest court has been charged with answering this complex question
Rodney Berget's lawyer doesn't think he deserves to die and says his client's constitutional rights were violated during the sentencing phase.
KSFY News was in court today to hear Berget's lawyer's reasoning.
The South Dakota Supreme Court was in Sioux Falls today. The court heard arguments from Berget's lawyer Jeff Larson and state attorney general Marty Jackley.
Larson argued the state violated three parts of the constitution.
Jackley argued Berget waived many of his rights throughout the process.
attorney Jeff Larson says his client didn't have the chance to confront a doctor's report used against him in sentencing.
Attorney Jeff Larson said "we agreed to file, under seal, with the agreement it could only be used if Dr. bean testified in court."
Larson argued the competency exam wasn't even brought up until sentencing.
"That's the first time we had noticed, that's why it's a due process violation, is 'how can you respond when the first time I hear about it is when the verdict is being announced.' I can't object at that point. he's reading the verdict and that's where the problem is," Larson said.
But attorney general Marty Jackley said using the report wasn't the state's doing.
"With respect to Dr. Bean, it's important to understand that the state didn't introduce Dr. bean's report, the defendant did. if you look at the record, it was the defendant that placed the report into evidence, it was not the state," Jackley said.
Larson also said Judge Zell was asked to do the impossible. In fact, he says Berget wasn't sentenced on his own.
"If he makes a factual finding different than what he does in Robert, he brings into question his findings in Robert, yet if he makes the exact same findings, he hasn't given Rodney Berget the individualized determination that the constitution requires," Larson said.
Overall, state attorney general Marty Jackley said the state has the right to use extra evidence.
"When the defendant enters into a knowing and voluntary plea as he did on November 17th, he's waived certain rights," Jackley said.
Larson argued Berget's constitution rights were violated in not being able confront Dr. Bean in court; the doctor's exam not being brought up until sentencing violated his right to due process; and the fact the doctor's report was used against him violated his 5th amendment rights against self-incrimination.
Larson said the judge sentenced Berget based on the case of Eric Robert, Berget's partner in crime during the attempted prison escape.
Jackley tells KSFY News the facts of the record as well as the law justifies the use of the death penalty.
Tuesday, December 3 2013 10:48 PM EST2013-12-04 03:48:06 GMT
Canton residents have voted down a proposal to build a new aquatic center. The city required 60% of voters to approve the bond to pass; only 50.9 voted yes. Canton financial officer Kyle Cwach said 412 votedMore >>
Canton residents have voted down a proposal to build a new aquatic center.More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 11:29 PM EST2013-12-07 04:29:51 GMT
With the Salvation Army Warming Center's doors not open yet, the Sioux Falls Police Officers have seen an increase of homeless people out on the streets in the below zero temperatures. KSFY's Tess HedrickMore >>
With the Salvation Army Warming Center's doors not open yet, the Sioux Falls Police Officers have seen an increase of homeless people out on the streets in the below zero temperatures. KSFY's Tess Hedrick took rode along with a Sioux Falls Police Officer Friday evening.More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 11:19 PM EST2013-12-07 04:19:35 GMT
HURON, S.D. (AP) - Governor Dennis Daugaard has announced the formation of a task force to find a balance between modern agricultural practices and wildlife-oriented land conservation. Daugaard madeMore >>
He's concerned about the declining pheasant population and its statewide impact.More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 11:08 PM EST2013-12-07 04:08:17 GMT
The Sioux Falls Police Department is asking for the public's assistance in locating a missing person that is memory impaired. The missing person is Leroy Harold ‘Bud' Anderson. He is a white male, 75More >>
The missing person is Leroy Harold ‘Bud' Anderson. He is a white male, 75 years old, 5' 10" tall 180 pounds, white hair, balding on top.More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 11:00 PM EST2013-12-07 04:00:52 GMT
LUCAN, Minn. (AP) - The names of the two children killed in a farmhouse fire in southwestern Minnesota this week have been released. The family identifies the victims as 7-year-old Hazel and 4-year-oldMore >>
The two were unaccounted for after the fire Wednesday. One of the children's bodies was found Wednesday, the other a day later.More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 7:27 PM EST2013-12-07 00:27:18 GMT
Every year the streets of downtown Dell Rapids fill up to welcome the holidays with open arms. But the recent blast of arctic air has forced organizers of Christmas at the Dells to make some changes. "IMore >>
Cold weather cancels outdoor portion of Christmas at the Dells annual holiday event.More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 6:47 PM EST2013-12-06 23:47:21 GMT
WCCO -- A family is western Minnesota is dealing with a tragic loss. Two of their children were unaccounted for after a fire started in their home Wednesday. The bodies of those children were found WednesdayMore >>
A family is western Minnesota is dealing with a tragic loss. Two of their children were lost in a devastating house fire Wednesday. More >>
Friday, December 6 2013 6:10 PM EST2013-12-06 23:10:35 GMT
The fate of South Dakota's minimum wage rests in the hands of voters, Secretary of State Jason Gant announced Friday. After passing the petition certification process, the issue is now known as InitiatedMore >>
The fate of South Dakota's minimum wage rests in the hands of voters, Secretary of State Jason Gant announced Friday.More >>