Former Moeller prosecutor reflects back on case - KSFY News - Sioux Falls, SD News, Weather, Sports

Former Moeller prosecutor reflects back on case

Posted: Updated:

The story of Becky O'Connell has made an impression on the lives of many here in Sioux Falls.

That includes those who fought for his execution.

KSFY News spoke with the original prosecutor in the case today.

Donald Moeller has been on death row for a little more than 20 years.

And a lot has happened in those two decades.

From computers, cell phones, the Internet and 9/11,  the country has changed, and so has Sioux falls.

Former Lincoln County prosecutor Jeff Masten says he's disappointed it took 22 years to get to this point.

"What's going to happen tonight, seems like it's out of some parallel universe. certainly happened in a different lifetime to me. So I guess, I'm a little bit numb feeling one way or another," Masten said.

One of the strongest memories masten has of the case is seeing Becky O'Connell's body for first time.

"We were pretty well decided that if there hadn't been a justification for a death penalty verdict before in the 20 years preceding in South Dakota, this sure as heck was going to be a death penalty case if we figured out who did it," Masten said.

Masten says the initial days of the case were a nail-biter.

"The thing that kept me up at night, and I think the thing that kept all 20 or so detectives up at night was just there wasn't a witness to the crime. all we had were some scattered circumstantial clues," Masten said.

Masten says he hates what Moeller did to South Dakota society.

It forced parents to keep their children closer to home.

"I think if you talk to any of the police officers or anybody who was actually around with younger children at that time, kids just disappeared off the street. and they certainly disappeared off playgrounds," Masten said.

Despite the crime's effect on the community, Masten holds no personal ill-will towards Moeller

"A long time ago a supreme court justice told me, that you hate the crime, you don't hate the man. I think that was good advice 30 years ago when he gave it to me and is just as good today," Masten said.

Much of Becky's story exists in the minds of people who lived through it.

The memories of Becky's death are as fresh today as they were 22 years ago.

But tonight, the execution of Donald Moeller brings closure for some.

  • Man accused of kidnapping South Dakota toddler arrested in Idaho

    Man accused of kidnapping South Dakota toddler arrested in Idaho

    Thursday, April 24 2014 12:35 PM EDT2014-04-24 16:35:01 GMT
    A 2-year-old will soon be reunited with her mother after she was kidnapped by her biological father and taken to Idaho.More >>
    A 2-year-old will soon be reunited with her mother after she was kidnapped by her biological father and taken to Idaho.
    More >>
  • Teen girls arrested in Cubby's robbery

    Teen girls arrested in Cubby's robbery

    Thursday, April 24 2014 12:03 PM EDT2014-04-24 16:03:15 GMT
    Two teenage girls were arrested in this week’s gas station robbery – not teenage boys as police initially suspected.More >>
    Two teenage girls were arrested in this week’s gas station robbery – not teenage boys as police initially suspected.
    More >>
  • Two young girls miraculously survive car crashing into their Sioux Falls home

    Two young girls miraculously survive car crashing into their Sioux Falls home

    Thursday, April 24 2014 11:53 AM EDT2014-04-24 15:53:28 GMT
    A Sioux Falls family is without a home this morning after a car drove into their home overnight.More >>
    Sioux Falls police say it’s a miracle two young girls are alive after a car crashed through a garage and into their bedroom overnight.
    More >>
  • Redfield man killed in fiery crash

    Redfield man killed in fiery crash

    Thursday, April 24 2014 10:24 AM EDT2014-04-24 14:24:46 GMT
    A Redfield man died in a one-vehicle crash near the intersection of 174th Street and 392nd Avenue about six miles east and one mile south of Redfield yesterday.More >>
    A Redfield man died in a one-vehicle crash near the intersection of 174th Street and 392nd Avenue about six miles east and one mile south of Redfield yesterday.More >>
  • 36th Kingswood Rummage off to good start

    36th Kingswood Rummage off to good start

    36th Kingswood Rummage off to good start

    Thursday, April 24 2014 9:58 AM EDT2014-04-24 13:58:42 GMT
    The 36th Annual Kingswood Rummage Sale started on Wednesday and runs through Saturday. Roughly 300 homes will participate this year and as the city continues to grow, more homes will do the same. More >>
    The 36th Annual Kingswood Rummage Sale started on Wednesday and runs through Saturday. Roughly 300 homes will participate this year and as the city continues to grow, more homes will do the same. More >>
  • Kingswood Rummage sale begins; some sellers working for a cause

    Kingswood Rummage sale begins; some sellers working for a cause

    Kingswood Rummage sale begins; some sellers working for a cause

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:50 PM EDT2014-04-24 03:50:58 GMT
    The 36th Annual Kingswood Rummage Sales BeginsMore >>
    The 36th Annual Kingswood Rummage Sales BeginsMore >>
  • No sound for Sioux Falls tornado siren test

    No sound for Sioux Falls tornado siren test

    No sound for Sioux Falls tornado siren test

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 10:22 PM EDT2014-04-24 02:22:37 GMT
    It is starting to warm up and spring has finally arrived, but with that, comes severe weather. This morning the tornado sirens were tested, but many in the Sioux Falls area did not hear them. The Emergency Manager for Sioux Falls said it was a communication problem. And other than that they are not exactly sure why it happened. We all know what the tornado siren means - potentially dangerous weather approaching. On Wednesday South Dakota had a state-wide test for when the storms roll through....More >>
    It is starting to warm up and spring has finally arrived, but with that, comes severe weather. This morning the tornado sirens were tested, but many in the Sioux Falls area did not hear them. The Emergency Manager for Sioux Falls said it was a communication problem. And other than that they are not exactly sure why it happened. We all know what the tornado siren means - potentially dangerous weather approaching. On Wednesday South Dakota had a state-wide test for when the storms roll through....More >>
  • Redfield family keeps local drive-in alive

    Redfield family keeps local drive-in alive

    Redfield family keeps local drive-in alive

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 7:43 PM EDT2014-04-23 23:43:58 GMT
    Catching a flick at a drive-in movie theater is almost a thing of the past.Several small town indoor theaters even have a hard time surviving.On easter day Redfield lost their cinema, and one local family was not about to let the town's drive-in close as well. “Our community is pretty small, and if it would close there is probably no chance it would open again, so we didn't want to see it close we wanted to continue to see it in our community,” Drive-in co-owner Stacey Marlow said. Painting, ...More >>
    Catching a flick at a drive-in movie theater is almost a thing of the past.Several small town indoor theaters even have a hard time surviving.On easter day Redfield lost their cinema, and one local family was not about to let the town's drive-in close as well. “Our community is pretty small, and if it would close there is probably no chance it would open again, so we didn't want to see it close we wanted to continue to see it in our community,” Drive-in co-owner Stacey Marlow said. Painting, ...More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KSFY. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service or our EEO Report.