Bill would eliminate mandate to add fluoride to drinking water - KSFY News - Sioux Falls, SD News, Weather, Sports

Proposed bill would eliminate state mandate to add fluoride to drinking water

Posted: Updated:

A new bill will hit the South Dakota Senate Local Government Committee on Monday that would take away the state's mandate for adding fluoride to drinking water. 

Since the 1970s, state and federal regulations made it mandatory to increase the level of fluoride in drinking water after research showed its benefits to preventing tooth decay. 

But after a few decades on the books, some South Dakota state legislators say its time to ask new questions. 

All water contains some level of fluoride. 

"It's naturally occurring in all waters but it varies depending on the water source," said Sioux Falls Dentist Anne Pillar. 

Decades ago health officials decided to set a standard level. 

"Back then they told us you will have 1.1 parts per million gallons of fluoride in your water, well naturally we have .4 so they've tripled the amount of fluoride that we put in our water," said South Dakota Representative Manny Steele.   

That decision was based on years of research from the medical and dental community.

"There have been nearly 70 years of research and practical experience showing that fluoride in our water is not only safe, but it drastically reduces dental decay in adults and children," said Pillar. 

But the South Dakota lawmakers behind the bill say it's time to have another conversation about the mandate. 

"We're waving a flag out there saying hey, should we do something about this, are we actually getting more fluoride than what a person should really have," said Steele.

Representative Steele says it's also about giving local governments the chance to ask those questions and discern the costs for themselves. 

"What does this cost us? Is the benefit that we're getting, can that justify the cost that we're getting the tax payer for?" said Steele. 

The dental community says the small costs far out-weigh the potential consequences without it. 

‘The cost to the individual tax payer would be 50 cents to 3 dollars per year and if you think of that in relative costs of dental care it could save you hundreds of dollars per year in dental bills," said Pillar. 

The current state mandate only applies to cities of 500 or more, so several rural communities in the state do not have the added fluoride in their water system. Pillar says people in those communities do see an increase in cavities and tooth decay.

  • Avera Medical Minute ASL: Meeting the need for Family Care Physicians

    Avera Medical Minute ASL: Meeting the need for Family Care Physicians

    Thursday, April 24 2014 10:00 PM EDT2014-04-25 02:00:12 GMT
    It's not always easy to attract new doctors to rural South Dakota. In Aberdeen, there's been a growing demand in the family practice field. At Avera St. Luke's hospital, they're meeting that need with exceptional talent. "Hi Mason! I'm Dr. Shawn, how are you my friend?" Asked Dr. Shawn Bartel, with Avera Aberdeen Family Physicians.The moment he walks in the door, you can tell Dr. Shawn Bartel loves what he does. As the newest face at the Avera State Street Medical Square, he's hit the ground ...More >>
    It's not always easy to attract new doctors to rural South Dakota. In Aberdeen, there's been a growing demand in the family practice field. At Avera St. Luke's hospital, they're meeting that need with exceptional talent. "Hi Mason! I'm Dr. Shawn, how are you my friend?" Asked Dr. Shawn Bartel, with Avera Aberdeen Family Physicians.The moment he walks in the door, you can tell Dr. Shawn Bartel loves what he does. As the newest face at the Avera State Street Medical Square, he's hit the ground ...More >>
  • Gravity coaster coming to Storybook Land

    Gravity coaster coming to Storybook Land

    Thursday, April 24 2014 8:18 PM EDT2014-04-25 00:18:49 GMT
    Storybook LandStorybook Land
    Storybook land is a place kids and parents can go to have a good time.“I come here with my dad and mom,” Joshua Chambers said. Chambers heads to the park often, and the Aberdeen Sertoma Club, and Parks and Recreation Department have some new ideas to bring a little more fun to the park“The first ride to be put in place will be the gravity coaster, it’ll be a really nice addition to the park,” Parks and Rec. Director Doug Johnson said. Right now storybook land has only a few rides, but what th...More >>
    Storybook land is a place kids and parents can go to have a good time.“I come here with my dad and mom,” Joshua Chambers said. Chambers heads to the park often, and the Aberdeen Sertoma Club, and Parks and Recreation Department have some new ideas to bring a little more fun to the park“The first ride to be put in place will be the gravity coaster, it’ll be a really nice addition to the park,” Parks and Rec. Director Doug Johnson said. Right now storybook land has only a few rides, but what th...More >>
  • Two young girls miraculously survive car crashing into their Sioux Falls home

    Two young girls miraculously survive car crashing into their Sioux Falls home

    Thursday, April 24 2014 7:40 PM EDT2014-04-24 23:40:41 GMT
    A Sioux Falls family is without a home this morning after a car drove into their home overnight.More >>
    Sioux Falls police say it’s a miracle two young girls are alive after a car crashed through a garage and into their bedroom overnight.More >>
  • Smartphone automatically posts selfies of man who took phone

    Smartphone automatically posts selfies of man who took phone

    Thursday, April 24 2014 7:35 PM EDT2014-04-24 23:35:05 GMT
    A Flandreau man tells us he lost his phone, and found a murderer. The person who unknowingly posted selfies to Facebook with the phone happened to be a wanted man, and a convicted murderer.More >>
    A Flandreau man tells us he lost his phone, and found a murderer. The person who unknowingly posted selfies to Facebook with the phone happened to be a wanted man, and a convicted murderer.More >>
  • 'Farmland' documentary featuring SDSU alumni premiering in Sioux Falls

    'Farmland' documentary featuring SDSU alumni premiering in Sioux Falls

    Thursday, April 24 2014 5:28 PM EDT2014-04-24 21:28:06 GMT
    Academy Award-winning filmmaker James Moll’s new feature length documentary, Farmland, will be released nationally May 1, 2014. Sioux Falls has been selected to host a premiere, and the film will come to Sioux Falls for a one-time showing on May 1 at 7 p.m. at the Century East at Dawley Farm theater.More >>
    Academy Award-winning filmmaker James Moll’s new feature length documentary, Farmland, will be released nationally May 1, 2014. Sioux Falls has been selected to host a premiere, and the film will come to Sioux Falls for a one-time showing on May 1 at 7 p.m. at the Century East at Dawley Farm theater.
    More >>
  • Spearfish couple finds mountain lion in front yard

    Spearfish couple finds mountain lion in front yard

    Thursday, April 24 2014 5:20 PM EDT2014-04-24 21:20:05 GMT
    A wildlife official says a mountain lion that was found in a tree at a Spearfish home was tranquilized and later released a few miles away in a rural area.More >>
    A wildlife official says a mountain lion that was found in a tree at a Spearfish home was tranquilized and later released a few miles away in a rural area.More >>
  • Relatives take suspects in Cubby's robbery to police

    Relatives take suspects in Cubby's robbery to police

    Thursday, April 24 2014 5:01 PM EDT2014-04-24 21:01:25 GMT
    Two teenage girls were arrested in this week’s gas station robbery – not teenage boys as police initially suspected.More >>
    Authorities say a woman and a girl suspected of robbing a store at a Sioux Falls gas station this week were taken to the police station by their relatives.More >>
  • San Diego Naval base on lockdown

    San Diego Naval base on lockdown

    Thursday, April 24 2014 4:59 PM EDT2014-04-24 20:59:38 GMT
    A San Diego naval base is on lockdown today after an unsubstantiated report of a person with a weapon, an official said.
    More >>
    A San Diego naval base is on lockdown today after an unsubstantiated report of a person with a weapon, an official said.

    More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KSFY. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service or our EEO Report.