Piper's attorney says court mishandled guilty plea - KSFY News - Sioux Falls, SD News, Weather, Sports

Piper's attorney says court mishandled guilty plea

Posted: Updated:

 "In South Dakota, if we must use the death penalty....shouldn't we at least make sure we do it right?" Steven Miller, the attorney for death row inmate Briley Piper.... confronts the South Dakota Supreme Court, saying an error was made in the decision making process that led to his conviction.

 Did Briley Piper understand what it meant when he plead guilty to the 2000 murder of Chester Allen Poage in Rapid City?

 Today before the Supreme Court, his attorney said "no"...there was a critical part of the process Piper didn't understand....and because of that the case should be reviewed again.

 "Why in the world are we here again? Let's just do it right."Attorney Steven Miller didn't parse words before the Supreme Court, telling the justices the lower court judge and Piper's previous attorneys gave him bad information, leading him to believe that by pleading guilty...which he did...his only option for sentencing was by a judge....which is not the case. "Before Briley Piper's choice to plead guilty made back in 2001...can be forever held against him ....it must be true that when he entered that plea ....not at some later time...but when he entered that plea.....he was given correct advice as to the rights he had and the fact he was waiving them."

 In 2011, the Supreme Court ordered a jury sentencing for Piper based on concerns over was piper was told.
 And that jury also sentenced Piper to death.
 Assistant Attorney General Paul Swedlund told the court, if there was a case where the death penalty was valid, this was it. "Over the course of a 4 hour long ordeal, Allen Poage was assaulted with a gun, kicked, bound, poisoned with acid, kidnapped, stripped naked, beaten, buried in a snowbank, shoved into freezing creek water, bludgeoned, taunted, scalped, drowned, stabbed, stoned and posthumously robbed."

 But Piper attorney Miller told the court, the entire process must be questioned because he maintains it did not serve Piper the way it should have.
 Assistant Attorney General Swedlund told the court....even if mistakes were made by Piper's attorneys in 2001....a court is not necessarily obliged to correct them. "Its not incumbent on the court to correct defense strategies."

 As with any Supreme Court appeal, there is no set timeline on when a decision will be rendered and announced.

  • Red Door Church holds large Easter Egg Hunt, Saturday

    Red Door Church holds large Easter Egg Hunt, Saturday

    Red Door Church holds large Easter Egg Hunt, Saturday

    Saturday, April 19 2014 11:10 PM EDT2014-04-20 03:10:32 GMT
    Easter weekend is here and thousands in Sioux Falls were up early Saturday morning to celebrate it. More >>
    Easter weekend is here and thousands in Sioux Falls were up early Saturday morning to celebrate it. More >>
  • O'Gorman H.S. students to perform "Shrek, the Musical"

    O'Gorman H.S. students to perform "Shrek, the Musical"

    O'Gorman H.S. students to perform "Shrek, the Musical"

    Saturday, April 19 2014 11:05 PM EDT2014-04-20 03:05:11 GMT
    "Shrek" The Musical is coming to Sioux Falls by way of students at O'Gorman High School.More >>
    "Shrek" The Musical is coming to Sioux Falls by way of students at O'Gorman High School.More >>
  • Drivers frustrated with road construction

    Drivers frustrated with road construction

    Drivers frustrated with road construction

    Saturday, April 19 2014 9:20 PM EDT2014-04-20 01:20:42 GMT
    Road construction is in full swing in Sioux Falls. Another round of improvements are underway along Russell Street.More >>
    Road construction is in full swing in Sioux Falls. Another round of improvements are underway along Russell Street.More >>
  • After long wait, ranchers find relief from USDA

    After long wait, ranchers find relief from USDA

    After long wait, ranchers find relief from USDA

    Saturday, April 19 2014 4:32 PM EDT2014-04-19 20:32:04 GMT
    After a devastating blizzard killed thousands of cattle in October, South Dakota lawmaker and rancher Gary Cammack wondered whether his state's ranching community could recover.More >>
    After a devastating blizzard killed thousands of cattle in October, South Dakota lawmaker and rancher Gary Cammack wondered whether his state's ranching community could recover.More >>
  • Sioux Falls Storm tackles child abuse, Saturday night

    Sioux Falls Storm tackles child abuse, Saturday night

    Sioux Falls Storm tackles child abuse, Saturday night

    Saturday, April 19 2014 3:57 PM EDT2014-04-19 19:57:19 GMT
    April is National Child Abuse Prevention month and in honor of it, the Sioux Falls Storm plans to spread awareness at Saturday night's game against the Wyoming Calvary.The Storm is partnering with Children's Inn, Waterbury Heating and Cooling, Coleman and Fluxxr to raise awareness about Child Abuse.The event will seek to fulfill three main goals: to raise awareness, to encourage strong families in the Sioux Empire and to raise money for the Children's Inn.Children's Inn offers shelter, crisis...More >>
    April is National Child Abuse Prevention month and in honor of it, the Sioux Falls Storm plans to spread awareness at Saturday night's game against the Wyoming Calvary.The Storm is partnering with Children's Inn, Waterbury Heating and Cooling, Coleman and Fluxxr to raise awareness about Child Abuse.The event will seek to fulfill three main goals: to raise awareness, to encourage strong families in the Sioux Empire and to raise money for the Children's Inn.Children's Inn offers shelter, crisis...More >>
  • Vikings to add another $1.2M to stadium project

    Vikings to add another $1.2M to stadium project

    Vikings to add another $1.2M to stadium project

    Saturday, April 19 2014 3:41 PM EDT2014-04-19 19:41:21 GMT
    MINNEAPOLIS (AP) - The Minnesota Vikings are contributing another $1.2 million to the new stadium to put in a bigger video board on the facility's west end and for other video-related upgrades.The funding was approved Friday by the Minnesota Sports Facilities Authority. It brings the total cost of the project from $975 million to $976.2 million.The team had initially agreed to contribute $477 million to the project. In November, the Vikings agreed to put up $26.4 million in contingency funds....More >>
    MINNEAPOLIS (AP) - The Minnesota Vikings are contributing another $1.2 million to the new stadium to put in a bigger video board on the facility's west end and for other video-related upgrades.The funding was approved Friday by the Minnesota Sports Facilities Authority. It brings the total cost of the project from $975 million to $976.2 million.The team had initially agreed to contribute $477 million to the project. In November, the Vikings agreed to put up $26.4 million in contingency funds....More >>
  • SD lottery offers losing tickets a second chance

    SD lottery offers losing tickets a second chance

    SD lottery offers losing tickets a second chance

    Saturday, April 19 2014 2:57 PM EDT2014-04-19 18:57:20 GMT
    PIERRE, S.D. (AP) - The South Dakota Lottery has announced a second chance game for players with losing scratch-off tickets.The program, called Play it Again, will launch next Wednesday. Members of the Lottery Players Club can enter non-winning tickets in an online drawing.Lottery executive director Norm Lingle says other states have similar games and gamers have asked for it in South Dakota. Lingle says second chance opportunities extend the length and value of games.The first game in the pr...More >>
    PIERRE, S.D. (AP) - The South Dakota Lottery has announced a second chance game for players with losing scratch-off tickets.The program, called Play it Again, will launch next Wednesday. Members of the Lottery Players Club can enter non-winning tickets in an online drawing.Lottery executive director Norm Lingle says other states have similar games and gamers have asked for it in South Dakota. Lingle says second chance opportunities extend the length and value of games.The first game in the pr...More >>
  • Railroad group says $1 million pledged locally

    Railroad group says $1 million pledged locally

    Railroad group says $1 million pledged locally

    Saturday, April 19 2014 2:53 PM EDT2014-04-19 18:53:21 GMT
    PIERRE, S.D. (AP) - A South Dakota organization that helps raise money for railroad rehabilitation says more than $1 million has been committed locally to help match a federal grant for which the state is applying.Rails to the Future says the state is seeking $12.6 million in a Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery (TIGER) grant. The state wants to rehab the state-owned railroad from Chamberlain to Presho.The entire project is estimated to cost $29 million. Earlier this month...More >>
    PIERRE, S.D. (AP) - A South Dakota organization that helps raise money for railroad rehabilitation says more than $1 million has been committed locally to help match a federal grant for which the state is applying.Rails to the Future says the state is seeking $12.6 million in a Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery (TIGER) grant. The state wants to rehab the state-owned railroad from Chamberlain to Presho.The entire project is estimated to cost $29 million. Earlier this month...More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KSFY. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service or our EEO Report.