McVay takes the stand in sentencing trial - KSFY News - Sioux Falls, SD News, Weather, Sports

McVay takes the stand in sentencing trial

Posted: Updated:

Admitted killer James McVay took the stand in his sentencing trial Friday afternoon.

McVay has pleaded guilty but mentally ill in the 2011 stabbing death of Sioux Falls hospice nurse Maybelle Schein.

Throughout his testimony, McVay repeatedly said he never wanted this sentencing trial to happen, saying he's simply allowing his attorneys to fight for his life. However, he says he is willing to accept any outcome.

Still McVay asserted that he is no longer a danger to others.

"If I was dangerous, then why am I not handcuffed? There are people here that would be perfect to hurt…but I haven't," said James McVay on the witness stand.

Before that statement, McVay outlines the details of Maybelle Schein's murder.

"The whole thing happened so fast...it took maybe 30 seconds for her to bleed out after I struck her artery," said McVay.

He also detailed Schein's struggle.

"You might call her an elder lady at 75, but she fought from beginning to end," said McVay.

His statements brought tears to the eyes of Schein's friends and family in the courtroom.

When State's Attorney Aaron McGowan asked McVay if he considers killing a 75-year-old woman to be depraved McVay responded:

"Yes, but that doesn't define me right now," said McVay.

He asserted that his actions should not define him as a person.

"I don't consider anyone evil. That's just a term we use to describe people," said McVay.

McGowan also gave the jurors a look at McVay's past homicidal tendencies, asking him about several threats he gave to doctors and inmates during his previous incarcerations.

"I decided I was going to do what you people can't do. I decided I was going to eliminate gang affiliates in the prison," said McVay when asked about his thoughts on killing a child rapist in the prison

McVay said he would have killed the rapist if he had the chance. When McGowan asked if he would harm any other inmates throughout the rest of his incarceration, McVay said no—he is no longer a dangerous person.

The sentencing trial is expected to wrap up early next week, but over the weekend the 12 jurors have been released as they consider whether or not to deliver the death penalty.

  • Owning Your Outdoors: Tree Care

    Owning Your Outdoors: Tree Care

    Friday, July 25 2014 9:36 AM EDT2014-07-25 13:36:12 GMT
    Doug says that the natural crown line of a tree should be easy to identify.Doug says that the natural crown line of a tree should be easy to identify.
    There are a number of reasons to prune and crown trees. Trees can grow to close to buildings, power lines or sidewalks and become a hazard. Trees can also be crowned and pruned to make them cosmetically more appealing.More >>
    There are a number of reasons to prune and crown trees. Trees can grow to close to buildings, power lines or sidewalks and become a hazard. Trees can also be crowned and pruned to make them cosmetically more appealing.More >>
  • Corsica cleans up after windstorm pummels town

    Corsica cleans up after windstorm pummels town

    Monday, July 28 2014 12:13 AM EDT2014-07-28 04:13:28 GMT
    While many were dealing with a wet Saturday, folks in the Central South Dakota community of Corsica faced gale force winds that left plenty of damage in their wake.More >>
    While many were dealing with a wet Saturday, folks in the Central South Dakota community of Corsica faced gale force winds that left plenty of damage in their wake.
    More >>
  • Avera Medical Minute ASL: relieving pain with hysterectomy

    Avera Medical Minute ASL: relieving pain with hysterectomy

    Sunday, July 27 2014 10:50 PM EDT2014-07-28 02:50:16 GMT
    It's not the easiest topic to discuss and no woman will tell you her cycle is a joyful experience. But for Wendy Mehlhaff, every month was accompanied by pain and discomfort.More >>
    It's not the easiest topic to discuss and no woman will tell you her cycle is a joyful experience. But for Wendy Mehlhaff, every month was accompanied by pain and discomfort.
    More >>
  • Tentative deal reached on VA Reform

    Tentative deal reached on VA Reform

    Sunday, July 27 2014 7:23 PM EDT2014-07-27 23:23:52 GMT
    The chairmen of the House and Senate Veterans Affairs committees have reached a tentative agreement on a plan to improve veterans' health care.More >>
    The chairmen of the House and Senate Veterans Affairs committees have reached a tentative agreement on a plan to improve veterans' health care.More >>
  • Gas Station clerk injured in armed robbery

    Gas Station clerk injured in armed robbery

    Sunday, July 27 2014 2:07 PM EDT2014-07-27 18:07:07 GMT
    Jackie HolmanJackie Holman
    A Sioux Falls gas station clerk was struck in the head with a handgun during an overnight armed robbery.More >>
    A Sioux Falls gas station clerk was struck in the head with a handgun during an overnight armed robbery.More >>
  • Celebration for Black Hills Cemetery Act

    Celebration for Black Hills Cemetery Act

    Sunday, July 27 2014 2:01 PM EDT2014-07-27 18:01:16 GMT
    Supporters of a bill that transfers ownership of nine historic cemeteries in the Black Hills from the federal government to local communities celebrated among the living and the dead.More >>
    Supporters of a bill that transfers ownership of nine historic cemeteries in the Black Hills from the federal government to local communities celebrated among the living and the dead.More >>
  • 2014 Mike Miller Night of Hope

    2014 Mike Miller Night of Hope

    Sunday, July 27 2014 12:14 AM EDT2014-07-27 04:14:24 GMT
    Sioux Falls was filled with some big name professional athletes Friday night for the Mike Miller Night of Hope benefiting the Sanford Children's Hospital.Sioux Falls was filled with some big name professional athletes Friday night for the Mike Miller Night of Hope benefiting the Sanford Children's Hospital.
    Sioux Falls was filled with some big name professional athletes Friday night for the Mike Miller Night of Hope benefiting the Sanford Children's Hospital.More >>
    Sioux Falls was filled with some big name professional athletes Friday night for the Mike Miller Night of Hope benefiting the Sanford Children's Hospital.More >>
  • Wind, hail brings widespread damage in Douglas County

    Wind, hail brings widespread damage in Douglas County

    Saturday, July 26 2014 11:45 PM EDT2014-07-27 03:45:21 GMT
    Strong wind and large hail hit parts of Douglas County near Corsica. More >>
    Strong wind and large hail hit parts of Douglas County near Corsica. More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KSFY. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service or our EEO Report.